Close Menu

Does A Broken Hip Usually Qualify As A Serious Injury Under Michigan Law?

Does A Broken Hip Usually Qualify As A Serious Injury Under Michigan Law

A broken hip from a car accident can disrupt almost every part of daily life. Walking might become hard or even impossible, and surgery could be needed. Getting back to work may take months. Some people need a walker, wheelchair, rehab, help at home, or ongoing medical care even after the bone heals. For older adults, the effects can be especially serious, as a hip fracture may lead to lasting loss of mobility and independence. If another driver caused the crash, a key legal question is whether the hip injury is serious enough to support a pain and suffering claim under Michigan law.

When we look at serious car accident injuries, we go beyond just the diagnosis. A broken hip is strong medical evidence, but Michigan law also looks at how the injury affects your body functions and daily life. Often, a broken hip shows serious impairment, especially if it leads to surgery, limited movement, long rehab, or lasting problems.

Michigan’s Serious Impairment Standard

Michigan’s No-Fault Act limits when an injured person may recover non-economic damages from an at-fault motorist. Under MCL 500.3135, a person may pursue damages for pain and suffering when the accident causes death, permanent serious disfigurement, or a serious impairment of body function.

Michigan law defines a serious impairment of body function through three basic requirements. The impairment must be objectively manifested; it must involve an important body function, and it must affect the injured person’s general ability to lead his or her normal life.

A hip fracture can meet all parts of this test, depending on the situation. X-rays, CT scans, MRIs, surgery notes, and doctor findings can clearly show the fracture. Walking, standing, balance, and moving your lower body are all important body functions. The main question is usually how much the injury changed your normal way of living.

Why A Broken Hip Frequently Meets The Threshold

A broken hip is not like a minor ache that goes away in a few days. Hip fractures often mean a hospital stay, surgery, rehab, physical therapy, using assistive devices, and long periods where you can’t put weight on your leg.

We look at what the person could do before the accident and what has become hard or impossible since then. Someone who worked full time before may not be able to go back to work. A parent might need help with childcare. An active retiree may lose the ability to walk alone, exercise, drive, shop, or join in social activities.

Under MCL 500.3135(5), there is no set minimum time that an impairment must last. The law asks for a close look at life before and after the injury. This matters a lot in hip fracture cases, since even if you get better later, the recovery can still cause major disruption.

Surgery Can Strengthen Evidence Of A Serious Impairment

Many traumatic hip fractures require surgical treatment. Depending on the location and severity of the fracture, doctors may use screws, plates, rods, or other hardware to stabilize the bone. Some patients require partial or total hip replacement.

We consider surgical records highly important because they document the severity of the physical damage and the treatment required to repair it. Surgery may also result in extended restrictions involving walking, driving, working, climbing stairs, lifting, or standing for long periods.

The legal question is still based on the individual facts, but a surgically repaired hip fracture accompanied by substantial functional restrictions can provide strong evidence that the serious impairment threshold has been satisfied.

Permanent Limitations Are Important But Not Always Required

A common misconception is that an injury must be permanent before an accident victim can pursue pain and suffering damages. Michigan law does not impose that requirement for a serious impairment of body function. Under MCL 500.3135, the duration of the impairment may be relevant, but there is no mandatory minimum length of time. A person who spends several months unable to walk normally, work, drive, or perform ordinary activities may potentially satisfy the threshold even if substantial recovery eventually occurs.

Permanent consequences can nevertheless make a claim more serious. Chronic pain, arthritis, reduced range of motion, altered gait, permanent lifting restrictions, or the need for future hip replacement surgery may significantly affect the value of a claim.

Older Adults May Experience More Severe Consequences

Hip fractures can be particularly damaging for older adults. A person who was independent before the crash may suddenly require assistance with bathing, dressing, transportation, cooking, household tasks, or mobility.

We look closely at that loss of independence when evaluating how the injury changed the person’s normal life. Michigan’s serious-impairment analysis is personal to the injured individual. The law does not require every injured person to have the same lifestyle or limitations.

An older adult who previously walked without assistance, drove independently, cared for a home, and participated in community activities may have a substantial claim when a traumatic hip fracture eliminates or restricts those abilities.

Michigan No-Fault Benefits And Hip Fracture Treatment

Pain and suffering damages are separate from Michigan Personal Injury Protection benefits.

Under MCL 500.3107, PIP benefits may provide payment for reasonably necessary accident-related medical care and rehabilitation, subject to the person’s applicable coverage and Michigan’s No-Fault rules.

For a hip fracture, medical treatment may include emergency care, hospitalization, surgery, medication, rehabilitation, physical therapy, assistive devices, and other necessary services. Certain injured people may also qualify for wage-loss and replacement-service benefits.

We examine both the No-Fault claim and the potential liability claim because each addresses different losses following a serious motor vehicle accident.

Frequently Asked Questions About Broken Hips And Michigan Serious Injury Claims

Does Every Broken Hip Automatically Qualify As A Serious Impairment Under Michigan Law?

No. Michigan law does not create a rule stating that every hip fracture automatically satisfies the serious impairment threshold. Under MCL 500.3135, we must evaluate whether the impairment is objectively manifested, involves an important body function, and affects the person’s general ability to lead his or her normal life. A broken hip often presents strong evidence on all three issues, particularly when it requires surgery, restricts walking, prevents work, or significantly interferes with ordinary activities.

Can We Pursue Pain And Suffering Damages For A Broken Hip?

Potentially, yes. If the hip fracture satisfies the serious impairment standard under MCL 500.3135 and another party is legally responsible for the accident, we may pursue noneconomic damages such as pain and suffering. The strength and value of the claim depend on the medical evidence, the impact of the fracture, fault for the collision, insurance coverage, and other circumstances.

What If The Broken Hip Heals After Several Months?

Recovery does not automatically defeat a serious impairment claim. Michigan law does not establish a minimum duration for an impairment. We examine how the fracture affected the person’s normal life while the impairment existed. Months spent unable to work, walk normally, drive, care for family members, or perform regular activities can remain significant even when substantial recovery eventually occurs.

Does Hip Replacement Surgery Make A Michigan Injury Claim More Serious?

Hip replacement surgery can be important evidence of the severity of an injury. It generally demonstrates significant structural damage and often requires hospitalization, rehabilitation, physical therapy, and extended activity restrictions. We also consider whether the person will require future treatment, whether the replacement creates permanent restrictions, and whether additional surgery may eventually become necessary.

What If The Accident Made A Pre-Existing Hip Problem Worse?

Having a previous hip condition doesn’t mean you can’t file an injury claim. We look at your health before the accident and compare it to your symptoms, treatment, and limitations afterward. If the accident made your condition worse or caused new problems, medical evidence can help show the connection between the crash and your increased impairment.

What Evidence Helps Prove A Serious Hip Injury Claim?

We rely on medical imaging, hospital records, surgical reports, orthopedic evaluations, physical therapy records, work restrictions, wage documentation, and evidence showing changes in daily activities. We may also document the need for walkers, canes, wheelchairs, home assistance, or modifications. Strong evidence should show both the physical injury and the practical consequences it created.

Talk To Ravid & Associates, P.C. About Your Hip Injury Claim

A broken hip can turn an independent, active person’s life upside down. We evaluate the medical evidence, treatment, functional limitations, future prognosis, and the effect the injury has had on everyday life when determining whether a claim satisfies Michigan’s serious impairment standard. We also investigate fault and available insurance coverage so that the entire claim is properly evaluated rather than focusing only on the fracture itself.

If you suffered a broken hip in a Michigan car accident, contact our Detroit auto accident attorneys at Ravid & Associates, P.C. today by calling (248) 948-9696 to receive your free consultation. We represent injured people in Detroit and throughout the entire state of Michigan from our office location in Southfield, Michigan. We can review your medical treatment, determine how Michigan’s serious injury threshold applies to your circumstances, investigate the accident, and pursue the compensation available under Michigan law.

Facebook Twitter LinkedIn
author avatar
Ravid & Associates, P.C.